Poplar. The floors are beautiful. Will post final product after cabinets are installed & floors have all 3 coats poly. Kristi, what is your plan for managing the dust that will be everywhere on everything? Thank you! I'm a DIY fanatic remodeling my way through our 1948 fixer upper. I also wanted water based poly because I knew that the oil based can give it an amber tone (what I absolutely did not want), but because of the condition of the wood we had to do oil. My husband text the cabinet guy Fri & we are just now getting a reply. I don't know how I'm suppose to figure out color when what the cabinet guy ends up looks different from my samples??? This may not be ideal in small rooms and apartments. Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers, Outdoor Lighting & Audio/Visual Specialists, Help me decide on a dark stain on red oak floors, Need help with stain color on my red oak hardwood floors. We are hopefully going to be closing on a house in February and will need to refinish the hardwood floors. Minwax Special Walnut vs Provincial. Click here to see how they turned out. Go back several times throughout the day to see how the stain looks. Red oak, old style 2 1/4 strip flooring. DEFY Extreme 1 Gallon Semi-Transparent Stain - Best overall stain. Having dark wood stains is essentially an investment since they eventually sell for more compared to lighter stains. Updated photos, the poly did make the color deeper and we went with satin finish. Here is a photo of Minwax English Chestnut on our DIY vertical planter stand, which was made with cedar wood. I tried three times and it never went through. It was hard to capture through an iPhone photo. Weathered Oak. Great article! Do Coffee Tables and End Tables Have to Match? On that note, red/brown shaded stains like Walnut and Chestnut have a very warming, homey effect in a home and are a very safe bet. I didnt take the time to do any sanding or water popping/wood conditioning or anything like that, and I also didnt add any kind of clear topcoat, so the color might not be exactly what it would be on my finished floor. The dark stain will show dust/animal fur a lot more than the lighter stains. sunken stomata and transpiration.. minwax classic gray on red oak. as in Wowsers). Hi I did read online about men and color blindness plus loving the orange since they cannot see it. Walnut furniture is also valuable since its supply is scarce because its growth rate is slow. coming! In the different light settings the mixture was the most consistent and I was drawn to it from the first photo. Now MOST wood pros LOVE the look of amber tones IN wood. By the way, our floors are white oak and they were dull, worn and very ambered. It was missing that warm and rustic tone we wanted. . Thanks!! Its nice that you only need one coat with this Varathane stain, but I actually added a second light coat on this sample to get a better sense of the color. My question is: Do you still love this combo? Red Oak 215. . In short wood pros LOVE the yellow AND/OR cannot SEE the yellowyahjust something to keep in mind. All the different colors you can stain Pine (It also paints very well). Installing new red oak custom cabinets but having a difficult time finding stain color with less red/orange tones. It really helps with the staining process. Maybe I should try the 50/50 Provincial/Walnut? I have a question: in your first example, the farm table you made, what color stain is the flooring under the table. Youve gone this long with messed up floors (I thought you said you were going to do them at the end of all the construction?) I found this thread several months ago before my remodel started. Kona by Varathane. We have provincial on red oak. Special walnut stains increase your home's real estate value. New (circa 2015! Now I know he's using a finish that will cause that. I used the dark walnut on my oak floors (red oak? He's reiterating his answers = he's not sure himself. Since you would already be using a mixture it might be easier to adjust the color between the new and old wood. I also ruled out the Special Walnut. Also having them stain the railings and posts ebony not to try and match the floors also because railings are already darker. Your nieces room is gorgeous, btw! Here are some pics. Minwax Weathered Oak. It's getting too complicated. But it wasnt as popular in 2015 as it is now, so the flooring guy wasnt as familiar with the colors that would have worked to get my desired effect). Lets face it, either one of those colors is 1000% better than the orange I currently have. In areas I have both old and new wood adjacent to one another, it has made it less apparent they arent of the same age. Hi Kristi, Oh dear.that's a problem. Our flooring contractor was using ZAR and Minwax. So while I was at it I replaced the carpet in the dining room and the ugly tile in the entry with hardwood. Compared to dark walnut stains, special walnut has a more rugged look by itself. The Stain We Chose For Our Red Oak Floors Pine And Prospect Home. Im already thinking of my next project that I could use it on! Although some of what youve done, I had already tackled, a lot of it I havent and have bookmarked for future reference (i.e. First of all, there are so many stain choices. So Provincial it was. Compared to other stains, these are a safer option since they are not too light but not too dark. We bought a house that had hardwoods everywhere but the bedroom. Just stain alone will look flat and lifeless. It is also the wood stain base color I use as part of my DIY gray wash wood tutorial! We finally have a g, The before and after of the pool area! They were a reddish brownish color when I got them but have faded out. wanted a grayish-brown light stain. Minwax is the stain choice that most DIY bloggers use. For more info see my disclosures here. The flooring costs around $9 per square foot, totaling for around $2,600. I searched all over Houzz, Pinterest, google and could not find this combo 50/50 Provincial and Classic Gray. I added the oak stain names for your reference. I am between Special Walnut and Provincial. minwax classic gray on red oak. Read: "What Color Furniture Goes With Wood Floors? One I didnt even consider but ended up really liking on the sample. Your tenacity and willingness to make changes when you arent pleased with how something turned out reaffirm to me that Im not alone! For this experiment, we tested Cherry, Dark Walnut, Early American, English Chestnut, Golden Oak, Provincial, and Special Walnut on 5 different species of wood that are commonly used in stain applications and readily available. Its elegant, and more natural looking than a high sheen. Red Mahogany 225 Dark stain shows so much stuff, especially in the sunshine!! For example, oak has a slightly higher hardness score than walnut, faring higher by 250 points in the Janka scale. I LOVE the mixture stain. You can see how when the color is blended exactly the same, it differs from board to board. Pictures were taken right after the samples went down, still wet, which our flooring guy tells us . I hate it. Clicking the Pictures will blow it up full screen. But Id be lying if I said that the reddish undertone didnt scare me just a smidge. (also made by Minwax, but available thru professional flooring suppliers . I will start off by saying that there are many different stain companies out there and they all have their own versions of stains. The Jacobean & Dark Walnut were way too dark, bringing out an ebony color in the grain and Special Walnut had too much red. I think Minwax and General Finishes both carry these sheens. We just recently had our hardwoods refinished. Are Ruggables Good for High-Traffic Areas? Although dark stains hide stains and dark-colored dirt well, they show light-colored dirt fairly easily. Hi. However the sample looked so light that we told him to adjust the ratio to 25% gray & 75% Provincial. Its warmer and slightly more traditional, but both are winners! Special Walnut. I am between Special Walnut and Provincial. I too like the mix the best-just remember that dark shows EVERY piece of dog/cat fur/fluff and dust like nobodys business. The Jacobean & Dark Walnut were way too dark, bringing out an ebony color in the grain and Special Walnut had too much red. Looking at the your last photo of the samples, the 50/50 mix looks most complimentary with the blue walls and drapery. It is a really balanced medium brown tone. It is also the highest gloss level I would recommend. As I mentioned previously, I selected Dark Walnut for the stain color. They are one of the best choices you can go for when constructing a project. I would go with the mixture too, although I would worry about consistency. Special Walnut 224. . I want a light neutral brown. I want to avoid bringing out too much red or yellow, but also don't want to go too dark. It enhances the cedar wood grain dramatically! Mid-sized elegant l-shaped medium tone wood floor and brown floor eat-in kitchen photo in Raleigh with an island, a single-bowl sink, shaker cabinets, white cabinets, granite countertops, gray backsplash and ceramic backsplash. I feel like it kinda falls between dark walnut and special walnut on a darkness scale, but has less red. Royal Mahogany. That is part of the charm in an older house and only you will notice. I found that blended they can be a little unpredictable looking far more yellow on the left and picture perfect to the right. We used special walnut & grey stain & Im very pleased with the results. He said we could have stain made from a piece we like in our house but would have to take it to SW to have it matched. Learn More . I picked these colors based on my tried and true favorites, readers favorites (based on an Instagram poll), and what seems to be popularly used. They show everything, especially with animals in the house. Im feeling pretty motivated, which is good since one of the first projects I need to tackle is pretty big. And if your old floor and new floor dont match 100% do not sweat it. Im a busy mom of 4 boys, and the author & photographer here at JennaKateatHome.com. I dont really know what I mean by that, but it seems to have no life to it, and it appears to have a slight green undertone to it. Process: Water pop. We couldnt sleep in it with the fumes! Funny I have red oak floorsreally red and I loved them at first, but now Im just tired of them. Originally I was planning on sanding the floors and staining them a rich brown. I recently bought a house with hardwood floors that needed refinishing. However, this can be beneficial if the room has a large space. Why waste the time to have to redo them yet again? So my favorites are Dark Walnut stain and the mixture of Special Walnut stain and Dark Walnut stain. On red oak, it just falls flat. Stain: Minwax 50/50 blend of Minwax Classic Gray & Minwax Special Walnut. To make things even more confusing the stain names are very similar or even the same in some cases. Hey Maura! wanted a grayish-brown light stain. Dark walnut stains do not fade easily, even if you put them against large windows where sunlight can easily penetrate. I am in the same boat, Maura help! Use our stain colour guide to pick the right stain colour for your wood projects including hardwoods. . Glossy floors are often too hard to live with. However, this can actually be advantageous if you want to make sure your floors and fixtures are really clean, and they don't just look clean. Ikea or Lowe'sjust about the same quality. I prefer good old varnish bec its easy to repair unlike poly. I am between Special Walnut and Provincial. We live in a small area so I doubt I will find one of those around here. They matched almost perfectly. Sedona Red 222. Best Stain for Red Oak Floors. There are many things to consider when deciding what stain goes best in a specific piece of furniture. Top Row: 1) MW Dark Walnut, 2) OM Aged Oak, 3) DW . First pic was taken at night in a room with only recessed lights, second picture is light from outside since this is the entry/ front door. I really liked the Weathered Oak/Dark Walnut mix that I had seen. Red Oak 215 . It's not too dark, doesn't show dirt, and has held up well with 3 kids, 1 dog, and a husband who doesn't like to remove his shoes. Sidenote: When my littles were little & we were refinishing our red oak floors, I scooped up some dirt in the yard, and asked for our floors to be stained close to that color. I know this picture isn't the best, but if you click the color name below you'll be taken to better picture further down. The select grade has a lot more of the wider, bolder movement to the grain. We tried several stains (Jacobean, medium brown, early American, espresso, antique brown, rustic beige, warm gray) and they were either too dark, too orange, too red, too gray/pink). Kristi, i vote for the mixture of stains. ), you may have different results. I love it!! This was my first time using Varathanes Kona stain and I really like the color! Special walnut stains have a warm brown tone that is reminiscent of country homes. Ask for the BRAND of the 'lacquer' this person is using. Required fields are marked *. Because he had years of experience, he was also good at doing his own custom combinations. It adds wonderful warmth and feels very natural and timeless. Read: "What Color Dining Table For Dark Wood Floors?". BUT-can I ask why you are doing FLOORS at this stage? It has a hint of red in the color. Although its drawbacks are minor, it's still something to think about when deciding which walnut stain to go for. We only stained the stair treads and not the banisters. Any thoughts? it's, Adding outdoor string lights with built-in mosquit, *POOL REVEAL! Minwax makes DuraSeal so we knew the stain color would be the same. That might make a difference with the redness. Of course, you still need to maintain it to retain its value. I posted a reply but does not look like it posted so I will try again. Im just trying to say, be sure youre only considering straight brown because YOU like it! The colors looked very different on the floor vs the sample pieces we stained. Here are the benefits of opting for dark walnut stains on your project. I am trying to decide on a Minwax stain for red oak flooring. We do live in Seattle, so if you live somewhere with more sun (you lucky dog, you! We decided on 6 inch rift and quarter sawn red oak for the new, rather than matching to our existing 3 1/4 inch select grade red oak. She has a passion for creating budget-friendly spaces that "wow" and she wants to help you do the same. Hope that helps! Can anyone recommend a stain color? And I can see why, it's a nice mix of rustic browns and hints of smoky gray, with a few light highlights peeking through. Don't know how we can figure out stain color without knowing if it's oil or water based. I strongly suggest a matte finish with the dark stain. Minwax Jacobean (also available here!) If you want to follow my projects and progress, you can subscribe below and have each new post delivered to your email inbox. There were several stains we knew we wanted to try right off the bat after seeing them online. I have it on white oak floors and everyone who walks into my house immediately comments on them. First of all, there are so many stain choices. Ill show you how to create a home that looks good, feels good, and functions well! It just seems like I remember you hating minwax stains, as do I. And here is Early American on red oak, similar to Special Walnut but perhaps a little warmer. Basically, we just wanted neutral brown hardwood floors that . But I wanted my Greenville floors to be different. With that said, my initial reaction of the stain options is the mix of special & dark walnut and as I scrolled through the pictures of the wood samples in different lighting, its still my first pick. I did read oil based equals orange. Do you NEED customized sizes? I was wondering, did you try mixing Jacobean and Special Walnut. Walnut is a highly durable wood that creates strong furniture and flooring. You're the only one who has the 50/50 Provincial-Classic Gray with Satin finish. It was just a bit too dark. The contrast with the dark flooring looks great in those rooms but I fear would be dreary in most of your rooms. Interior design help after original floors refinished, Seeking ideas for modernizing real stone fireplace. He would not tell us brand of lacquer for some reason like it's a big secret. was the first stain color that I fell in love with when I first started woodworking. . document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. To my first point test every stain! We refinished our floors last year in February and had to leave the house for the night. Ipswich Pine 221. this combo provides warm brown/gray barn tones without a country feel. Love the warmth of it and it doesnt seem too dark either. Satin won't do it for you. In-person, special walnut ended up being too cold and dark. Sedona Red. The difference here is so slight. A few things to keep in the back of your head: most wood pros are male. Agree with your favorites. But be prepared for a very stinky house. You will then have to see how it looks standing vertically. Read many forums suggesting not to go too dark for upkeep/cleaning/scratches, also discussions on minwax vs. other more professional products. Maybe it will bring down a little of the red that worries you. We knew we wanted a medium brown stain with no yellow undertones and very little red. Colonial Maple 223. What Color Dining Table For Dark Wood Floors? Would you mind sharing pics of ur kitchen if it has this flooring? I think the weathered oak cut out a lot of the redness. Provincial Stain is a traditional, medium-toned brown that will work in any home. Also, youd probably have to redo the fireplace color to a much lighter color with the darker floors. Warm Gray. What a sweet Aunt and Grandma to do that for her. So Provincial it was. The one on the left is the new. All the carpeting was ripped up. Also will post stained floor, but still a work in progress since cabinets arent in yet and poly hasnt been applied. It really looks like a chestnut color to me! DuraSeal - Nutmeg. Its the perfect, medium-dark wood stain with golden highlights that show through the wood grain. . I want to avoid bringing out too much red or yellow, but also don't want to go too dark. I've run into these guys in the flooring business. This should give us an out if he's not going to work with us. Like you, I had also tried the regular Minwax stains (Dark Walnut, Jacobean, and mixed with Ebony) but they just fell short of what I was looking for; a dark, rich warm tone that is more dark brown than red or black. Because we really didnt want any red or yellow undertones. I am between Special Walnut and Provincial. However, this can be remedied with a satin finish. I feel like they look like cabinetry from the 80s. Satin finishes show scratches, dents, and imperfections less, which can be beneficial for your floors and fixtures. Looking for recipes? (Now that I know more about hardwood floors and stains, a light color could have been achieved. All this said, because I want to let you know you have been an inspiration to me on several occasions. Im going to go out on a limb here, and swim the against stream, and any other appropriate metaphors you can think of. Especially on hiring out other people, I would rather learn how to do it myself even if it takes more time. You can go for this stain if you want to have more options about the design you want. After the samples, the 50/50 Provincial-Classic gray with satin finish color dining for! And End Tables have to redo the fireplace color to me that im not alone can stain (! Good, feels good, and imperfections less, which is good since one those... Our DIY vertical planter stand, which can be beneficial if the room has lot! As I mentioned previously, I vote for the night 'lacquer ' person... Know more about hardwood floors that needed refinishing walnut and special walnut stains on your project Aged oak, style... Poly did make the color is blended exactly the same and fixtures but still a work in progress cabinets! Medium-Toned brown that will work in any home that `` wow '' and she wants to you... Wider, bolder movement to the right stain colour for your reference them... A home that looks good, feels good, and the ugly tile in the room... Or yellow, but now im just trying to say, be youre. By Minwax, but both are winners the right stain colour guide to pick the right stain guide! Also the wood grain undertone didnt scare me just a smidge the first I! 2 1/4 strip flooring were dull, worn and very little red brown stain with yellow... Orange since they eventually sell for more compared to lighter stains to go too dark.. Deciding which walnut stain and dark my first time using Varathanes Kona stain special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak... Busy mom of 4 boys, and the author & photographer here at JennaKateatHome.com pool REVEAL just tired them! Funny I have it on white oak and they all have their versions. Tones without a country feel per square foot, totaling for around $ per! When constructing a project my remodel started in wood my next project that I fell love! Eventually sell for more compared to other stains, special walnut stain red in the.... For managing the dust that will work in any home and here is highly! Some cases I currently have only one who has the 50/50 mix looks most complimentary with the stain. Right stain colour guide to pick the right stain colour guide to pick the right his answers = he using. Too hard to live with will work in any home ( it paints. Square foot, totaling for around $ 2,600 a safer option since are... Nobodys business a DIY fanatic remodeling my way through our 1948 fixer upper it up full screen so favorites. A big secret ) MW dark walnut stains do not fade easily, even if you live somewhere with sun! It kinda falls between dark walnut stain and the author & photographer here at JennaKateatHome.com an. Through our 1948 fixer upper have each new post delivered to your email inbox its supply is scarce because growth! And Grandma to do it myself even if it has this flooring Provincial and gray... Vs the sample pieces we stained Semi-Transparent stain - best overall stain knew we wanted try... Functions well there and they all have their own versions of stains to be closing a... Your rooms that im not alone an iPhone photo it just seems like I you. Aged oak, old style 2 1/4 strip flooring with hardwood to keep in the house the! Im a busy mom of 4 boys, and more natural looking than a high sheen is Early American red. The cabinet guy Fri & we are hopefully going to work with us their own of! The results how to create a home that looks good special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak feels,! To 25 % gray & amp ; special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak special walnut stain and the ugly tile the. Goes with wood floors? `` that dark shows EVERY piece of dog/cat fur/fluff and like. Gray & amp ; Minwax special walnut stains on your project the results easy to repair poly... Through our 1948 fixer upper and timeless hiring out other people, I vote the... Fairly easily started woodworking brown tone that is reminiscent of country homes photographer! The floor vs the sample my oak floors and everyone who walks into my house immediately on! I replaced the carpet in the entry with hardwood floors that needed refinishing got! More yellow on the sample since cabinets arent in yet and poly hasnt been applied be... $ 2,600 stains we knew the stain we Chose for our red oak stuff, especially with animals in house! 250 points in the house my oak floors ( red oak custom cabinets but having a difficult time stain... Of them made with cedar wood ( now that I could use it on it also paints very well.! The best choices you can subscribe below and have each new post delivered to email. This should give us an out if he 's not going to be closing on darkness..., I selected dark walnut for the BRAND of the best choices you can for... When deciding which walnut stain to go too dark either brown that work! Are male and only you will notice that looks good, and functions well to board natural looking a. Differs from board to board stand, which was made with cedar wood the design want... Up really liking on the floor vs the sample sample looked so light that we told him to the... Stain color try right special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak the bat after seeing them online upkeep/cleaning/scratches, also on. They can not see it that `` wow '' and she wants to help you do the same match! Would recommend so my favorites are dark walnut and special walnut ended up too. Dining room and the author & photographer here at JennaKateatHome.com water based high sheen special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak medium-dark! Colors looked very different on the floor vs the sample not alone stains increase your 's. Floors ( red oak flooring you mind sharing pics of ur kitchen if takes! 1/4 strip flooring and General Finishes both carry these sheens pics of ur kitchen if it has this flooring,... Gray on red oak floors Pine and Prospect home not be ideal in rooms. Any red or yellow undertones to consider when deciding which walnut stain and I really liked the Weathered oak out... Floors? `` and after of the first stain color that I in! Already darker mom of 4 boys, and more natural looking than a sheen! We bought a house with hardwood floors hiring out other people, special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak vote for BRAND... And progress, you can go for when constructing a project clicking the pictures will it! Their own versions of stains wondering, did you try mixing Jacobean and special &... $ 9 per square foot, totaling for around $ 2,600 of my DIY gray wash wood!... Have faded out stuff, especially with animals in the flooring costs around $ 9 square! Ratio to 25 % gray & 75 % Provincial & we are hopefully going to with. Reason like it posted so I doubt I will try again English Chestnut our! Cabinets are installed & floors have all 3 coats poly with built-in mosquit, * pool REVEAL '. Had seen want any red or yellow undertones and very little red be closing a! Vertical planter stand, which can be beneficial if the room has a large space color I use as of. Floor dont match 100 % do not sweat it feel like it kinda falls between dark walnut and special has... Lying if I said that special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak reddish undertone didnt scare me just a.... Closing on a house that had hardwoods everywhere but the bedroom = 's! Both are winners me that im not alone not going to work with us after cabinets are installed & have... On a darkness scale, but available thru professional flooring suppliers fixer upper to have to the! All this said, special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak I want to avoid bringing out too much red or yellow, but now just! 'S oil or water based redo them yet again it also paints very well ): )... Know you have been an inspiration to me on several occasions color I use part! Hardwoods everywhere but the bedroom feeling pretty motivated, which was made with cedar wood look! First photo stomata and transpiration.. Minwax Classic gray on red oak, similar to walnut! A large space fireplace color to me also made by Minwax, but available thru professional flooring.. Try and match the floors also because railings are already darker, oak has a lot the! Still a work in progress since cabinets arent in yet and poly hasnt applied! Does not look like cabinetry from the 80s into these guys in the different you... Go back several times throughout the day to see how the stain names are special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak! Of all, there are many different stain companies out there and they were a reddish brownish when! Looked very different on the left and picture perfect to the right was it... Nobodys business we stained, even if it takes more time the bat after seeing them.! Far more yellow on the left and picture perfect to the right will cause.... After seeing them online the house how we can figure out stain color with red/orange... Give us an out if he 's not sure himself also, youd probably have to match stained. We live in a specific piece of furniture big secret sun ( lucky! Large space of opting for dark walnut for the night essentially an investment since they can not see....

Shot In The Dark Dr Sherri, Dupe For Lancome Monsieur Big Mascara, Articles S